The internet-indie-hype machine is generally alot more accurate than any paper based hype machine. The dynamic nature of the internet means that a band cannot hide it’s shittyness from the critiquing masses; if your album sucks, everyone will say so via blogs, comments and forums. It you slip enough cash to a magazine, I’m sure that you can convince them to write a favourable enough review of any band’s album.
That’s why ‘Bitte Orca’ is a great case study. Previous works by Dave Longstreth’s Dirty Projectors haven’t really been widely hyped, even if they have been critically praised . ‘Bitte Orca’ however has been proclaimed as the album to thrust them into indie stardom and when you consider the fact it was leaked on the net some months ago and people are still way excited about it, it’s hard not to get curious.
As a body of work it’s a crazy mis-mash of a thing. ‘Eclectic’ would be a flattering description, one that would imply the album has some sort of structure; it’s an album that will leave you wondering “how the hell are they going to play this live?”, but, equally, it will leave you wondering “I would sell my stuff to see them play this live”.
Winding through a range of time signatures, soundscapes and moods, ‘Bitte Orca’ is a monster with so many personalities it’s unsettling. Beautiful, quirky, surprising, spasmodic, filled with guitars, soaring vocals, stuttering grooves, confusing time signatures; it is the musical equivalent of a two year olds attention span.
Tracks like “Stillness Is The Move” - which sits like a piece of Sheena E inspired new wave punk - contrast with others like “Useful Chamber” - featuring nutball guitar breaks and a bridge that seems like it was written for another song (but, bizarrely seems to fit perfectly into this one). Elsewhere, “No Intention” swaps a sensible ‘clap your hands beat’ for a mid-song mandolin/guitar duel which again seems to be completely out of place.
I know it all sounds confusing (and, in truth, for the first few listens, you are left feeling very confused), but somehow the cut and paste feeling is superceeded by the crafted pop that results. Nowhere is this more apparent than the smile inducing “Temecula Sunrise”; stuttering beats shake the track along like a train, while guitars and shrieking choral backing vocals paint colours over the boyish vocals of Longstreth. To me, it is the indie version of “Ventura Highway”, dark, moody verses broken by a rising and anthemic chorus. Singing along is a guilty pleasure that’s impossible to deny.
Is the hype warranted? Yes. But in true indie fashion, this album is destined to be a cult hit. I’m 99% sure that you won’t be finding this album sitting in any charts (or iTunes featured lists); but in all honesty it should be. It is an amazing listen, and another stand out album to take in in 2009.
Stream ‘Bitte Orca’ now (via NPR.org)